The Exquisite Pleasures of Smoking

H/T Simon Clark for The Pleasure of Smoking.

It was actually a bit of a surprise to read something which had a title like “The Pleasure of Smoking”. After all, in this relentlessly negative era, how often does smoking ever get associated with pleasure? It’s not often you read about The Joys of Smoking, or The Delights of Smoking, is it? Which is why I amplified The Pleasure of Smoking into The Exquisite Pleasures Of Smoking as a title for this piece.

Tobacco Control works ceaselessly to defame and smear the gentle habit of smoking, in much the same way that sex used to be relentlessly associated with VD (venereal disease), as if the only thing anyone could possibly ever get from any sexual encounter was a dose of the clap. Or alcohol was associated so strongly with alcoholism that the only possible outcome of drinking a beer was lifelong slavery to the bottle. So it’s refreshing to see a different approach being adopted.

Nevertheless, this is a report written from a Tobacco Control perspective:

This research has provided considerable detailed information on the way in which smoking is viewed by a group of confirmed smokers. This is a group whose opinions are rarely articulated. The implications of these findings from a smoking cessation perspective are significant because there is a clear gulf between the way smoking is typically viewed as a negative, somewhat reprehensible behaviour, and how the smokers themselves saw their smoking as a source of pleasure, a choice rather than an addiction. Whilst it may be objected that “Smokers would say that, wouldn’t they?”, if stop smoking services are going to succeed in engaging with those smokers who continue to smoke in the face of the extensive efforts aimed at encouraging smoking cessation they are going to have to be prepared to engage with smokers on the terms upon which those individuals view their own behaviour. This includes being willing to recognise the pleasurable elements of smoking.

I often wonder at the complete failure of Tobacco Control to “engage with” confirmed and unrepentant smokers like myself. They only seem able to deal with those smokers who have already swallowed most of the antismoking propaganda. They are at a complete loss over what to do with those smokers who haven’t.

In fact, I don’t think it’s possible for any of these people to ever “engage with” someone like me: the defences are simply far too deep, the ramparts too high, the barbed wire too dense, the machine-guns too active.

And furthermore it would seem to defeat their purposes if they were to admit that smoking has any pleasures at all. For once the pleasurable nature of smoking has been conceded, how is one ever going to get any smoker to consider giving up smoking?

Along with the goal of reducing smoking prevalence these tobacco control measures have sought to denormalise smoking. Over time smoking has shifted from being seen as a socially accepted even desirable activity to being viewed as a stigmatised and socially frowned upon activity engaged in by a minority of people who require help to quit.

I think that, among smokers, smoking has never been denormalised at all. When, in summer, smokers gather together in pub gardens, they smoke as openly and normally as they ever have. And they no more talk about smoking than they ever used to do: i.e. not at all. Smoking has only been denormalised among those people who are susceptible to propaganda campaigns, much in the way that climate alarmism is only prevalent among those people who are easily persuaded by climate scientists and other self-styled experts. Some people – perhaps even most people – believe everything they’re told, and some people – perhaps only a few people – don’t.

Advertisements

About Frank Davis

smoker
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to The Exquisite Pleasures of Smoking

  1. Mark Jarratt, , Pt Arthur, Australia says:

    Yes smoking is enjoyable. Smoking remains a pleasurable pastime and an intermittent temporary respite from our daily duties and obligations. I too remain “confirmed and unrepentant”. The more the health cultists (aka those who know what I value and how I should live) inflict their petty neurotic tyranny the more I and others who support free choice, like the subscribers and contributors to Frank’s fine blog, will fight! I just hiked the 3 Capes – 39km of spectacular temperate coastal rainforest in SE Tasmania. I was the only smoker of 12 keen hikers. Like most reasonable people who aren’t puritanical ANTZ, my fellow hikers accepted my periodic delectation of (half drenched) Camel Blue in normal packs provided I didn’t blow smoke at them, and used my portable ashtray. General courtesy. Govt hyper regulation not required! Voracious leeches were much more of a problem (real leeches, not the tobacco tax and ban variety).

  2. Frank Davis says:

    We’re constantly told that 70% or 80% of smokers want to stop smoking. But one chart from this report gives the lie to this:

    Figure 1. Proportion of participants (n = 575) reporting beliefs about whether they will have stopped smoking inthe immediate, near, or distant future or not quitting at all.

    The chart doesn’t actually include a mention of “not quitting at all”. Perhaps that’s simply inconceivable to TC, and so they replaced that with “not quitting until well into the future” (which could mean anything). In fact, I can’t see what the difference between “the distant future” and “well into the future” might be. But add both together and 92% of smokers don’t envisage stopping smoking any time soon, which must also mean that they have no wish to stop smoking any time soon.

    Grandad makes much the same point, but failed to add 15% to the 77% figure he gives.

  3. nisakiman says:

    Well I rather anticipate that I will have stopped smoking in the not-so-distant future, given that I’m 67 now and don’t expect to live forever. And when I stop smoking, inescapably I will also stop breathing. But the fact remains that I will stop smoking at some point; that is inevitable.

  4. Clicky says:

  5. Pingback: Cigarettes Are Little Friends | Frank Davis

  6. Pingback: Tobacco Control Must Be Destroyed | Frank Davis

No need to log in

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s