The Demon-Haunted World

I was wondering this morning how I would have reacted to the election of Hillary Clinton as President of the United States. I thought she would have made a dreadful president, but if she’d been elected I would have swallowed hard, gritted my teeth, and got on with life. It wouldn’t have been the end of the world. Not immediately, anyway.

Instead, Donald Trump got elected. The result, you’d think, was as if the Devil himself had been elected President:

Hundreds joined a Friday afternoon “love rally” in Washington Square Park in Manhattan.

Leslie Holmes, 65, a website developer from Wilton, Connecticut, took an hour-long train ride to the demonstration — her first protest since the 1970s, when she hit the streets of San Francisco to oppose the Vietnam War.

She described herself as an armchair liberal but declared, “I’m not going to be armchair anymore.”

“I don’t want to live in a country where my friends aren’t included, and my friends are fearful, and my children are going to grow up in a world that’s frightening, and my granddaughters can look forward to being excluded from jobs and politics and fulfilling their potential, so I’m here for them,” she said.

I’m more or less the same age as Leslie Holmes. I’ve also been a website developer. And if I’d lived in San Francisco in 1970 I’d most likely have been an anti-war protester. Back then I would have shared pretty much all her values. I know what they are. Peace. Love. Long hair. Pot. Music. And hours and hours of incoherent conversation.

The post-war generation has demonised everything. They demonise capitalism. And they also demonise carbon dioxide. And they demonise tobacco. And now they’ve just demonised Donald Trump. When they say he’s racist and sexist and fascist, the confection of all these adjectives adds up to one thing: the demonic.

But if I would have shared Leslie Holmes’ values 50 years ago, where did those values come from? They are the almost universal values of an entire generation, all over the world. How did that happen?

The answer, I suspect, lies in the shared experience of that generation. And the one shared experience they all had was a TV rear-view mirror view of two global wars, trench warfare, mushroom clouds, concentration camps, and gas chambers. It was an utterly hideous vision. It was the vision of a nightmarish, terrifying, demonic world inhabited by demons like Hitler and Stalin, and whole armies of lesser demons.

The post-war generation inhabited a demonic world in which the devil had taken control. They saw demons everywhere. And they still do. It’s burned into them. And they’re always finding new demons. Donald Trump is their latest new demon.

I was always rather surprised that my parents and grandparents didn’t see the world in the same way that my generation did. They had, after all, actually lived through the wars. My grandfather had arrived in the trenches of WW1 on the day the war ended. None of them seemed scarred by the experience of being bombed and blitzed and blown to pieces. Going to war seemed to have been for them not much different from going shopping. It was something that had to be done. And when it was over and done with, they got on with doing whatever needed to be done next. It was their children who were traumatised, not them.

Why was that? Why were they not traumatised, while their children were? Perhaps because, after the war, the events of it became mythologised, glamorised, fictionalised, exaggerated. The war became a war movie, rather like the old American West became glamorised and enhanced into a fictional world populated by Gary Cooper gunfighters, in which the good guys became saints, and the bad guys became demons. My parents and grandparents had lived through the reality, but we, their children, inhabited magnified fictional memories of it. In Britain one of these was the 25-part TV documentary series The Great War. At least one fictional element of this was that it was all shot in black and white, which served to dramatise it. A second fictional element was that the battles followed each other in rapid succession: this week Verdun, next week the Somme. In this manner WW1 became a non-stop barrage of bullets and bombs from start to finish, under the leadership of demonic generals who fed men into it like meat into a mincing machine.

This collective false memory is what underpins the political project of the European Union. There’s a shared wish that such terrible wars should never happen again. And the simplistic proposed solution has been to try to dissolve the warring nations of Europe into one single European state, as if French and Germans only went to war simply because they were distinct separate French and German nations, and not for any other reason. Erase the distinctions, erase the borders, and – voilà – war becomes impossible.

But the result is that we now have this new European superstate on the brink of war with a Russia that lies outside its borders, and calling for a European army to meet the supposed threat. And the open borders within the EU have allowed a huge influx of refugees from beyond its borders. The solution to one problem has caused new (and entirely foreseeable) problems.

We could all do with stopping demonising everything. Donald Trump isn’t a demon. Neither is Hillary Clinton or Barack Obama. Nor is pot, or tobacco, or alcohol, or carbon dioxide. Nor are nation states. Nor are the Russians. Nor is Islam.

And nor, dare I say it, were Hitler or Stalin. We could do with movies in which Hitler and Stalin are portrayed as kindly, affable characters facing terrible choices. Saddam Hussein and Gaddafi too.

Demonising people and demonising things doesn’t help. It doesn’t provide any insight or understanding. It’s a knee-jerk reaction.


About Frank Davis

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

19 Responses to The Demon-Haunted World

  1. Roobeedoo2 says:

    Demonize something, then don’t be surprised if you create a demon.

    As far as ‘The Righteous’ (h/tip Leg-iron) goes, the only thing I feel towards them is pity and a little bit of gratitude because, if I’m totally honest, without them, I’d probably wouldn’t be as curious as I am right now…

  2. garyk30 says:

    Leftists must invent demons; otherwise, they might have to face the fact that the vast majority of adults reject their Utopian fantasies.

    If not for their demons, they would have to admit that most adults find their cherished ideals irrelevant and possibly dangerous to society at large.

    They have to try to scare people with demons in order to get anyone to pay attention and listen to them.

    • Barry Homan says:

      Gary, it’s what I’ve maintained and believed from the start of all these smoking bans: an anti-smoker is, at the core of his soul, simply a person who craves attention. Someone with an inferiority complex. An outcast, a square peg.

    • They first invented the LC and smoking scare then moved onto SHS,GLOBAL COOLING THEN TO GLOBAL WARMING then to climate change. All are made up scares over nothing if anyone had half a brain theyd laugh their butts off at the mere mention of the sky is falling ferry tales. Yet that’s all they ever had to push their agenda globally.

      It was a total plan for nothing but global terrorism against everyone……….Control control control.

      Lets hope the Trump win and Nigel Farage can lead the world back into a free world.

  3. Steven says:

    The amusing thing is in America you have the democrats and in the uk you have the liberal democrats.Perhaps they should both change their names as they are hardly democratic.

  4. It appears the guardians down and out

    David Hockney: Current is at NGV International until 13 March

    Since you’re here …

    …we have a small favour to ask. More people are reading the Guardian than ever but far fewer are paying for it. And advertising revenues across the media are falling fast. So you can see why we need to ask for your help. The Guardian’s independent, investigative journalism takes a lot of time, money and hard work to produce. But we do it because we believe our perspective matters – because it might well be your perspective, too.

    Fund our journalism and together we can keep the world informed.

  5. Ana says:

    Who is going to stand up for the England of freedom? Baldwin, Attlee, Churchill, Macmillan and Wilson were five Prime Ministers who smoked. They wouldn’t believe what has happened to this country.

    The low-grade, low-intellect people now ruling us seem to have no vision at all.
    Mr Lansley, Mr Cameron, Mr Miliband, Mr Clegg: Keep out of my life. I don’t want your dreary view of life infecting me. It’s not good for my health, or others around me.

    Read more:

  6. waltc says:

    The progressive media (aka the media) is now emitting over the top paranoia. Here’s an all too typical example

    The thing is, like kids ripely imagining The Monster In The Closet, they created this Monster all by themselves and now believe utterly in their own creation –though it has to be said that, unlike the rest of their amazingly unfounded political caricatures (Romney as misogynist; Bush as racist) Trump did manage to hand them a few good Once Upon a Times with which to begin their hysterical narrative, itself a kind of cockeyed historical pastiche, mixing Hitler and Jim Crow You’re right: demonization is an old trick. And applies equally to stamping dead bodies on Camels and scrawling Here Be Dragons on maps of the realm.

    Otoh, actual demons exist and just because Trump and tobacco aren’t, doesn’t mean Hitler and Stalin weren’t. Or that ISIS isn’t. That they cheapen the concept of “child abuse” by defining it as smoking within miles of a toddler, doesn’t mean that children aren’t actually beaten.

No need to log in

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.